A quiet condominium terrace with a teak lounge chair overlooking the broad blue-green river in Fort Myers.

What a Riverfront Address on First Street in Downtown Fort Myers Buys You Now

  • November 19, 2026

The developers of ONE, the 21-story condominium tower going up along the Caloosahatchee in downtown Fort Myers, once showed off their project from inside a house across the street. Gulfshore Business reported that the group met at 2582 First St., a three-story home built in 1907, where a north-facing window on the third floor looks out at the tower taking shape. From that window you can see the two kinds of value on this block: a restored house you can move into now, and a new tower you are buying ahead of a riverfront that is still under construction.

A buyer comparing downtown Fort Myers with other parts of Southwest Florida has probably seen the regional condo median by now. That number says almost nothing about First Street. Here, the price of a riverfront address mostly depends on which completion date you are buying into.

Three Prices on One Block

ONE will have up to 34 residences across 21 stories, with most floors holding two units. Two elevators serve the tower: one opens directly into each residence and the other is for guests. Gulfshore Business reported prices starting at $1.3 million and running to $2.5 million, with a full-floor penthouse at about $4 million. The top two floors sold together as one combined penthouse for $5.3 million. Jaxi Builders expects to finish construction by the end of 2027. The builder's vice president put construction cost at about $50 million and said securing entitlements took roughly three years.

The house across the street is the restored side of the same block. Gulfshore Business reported that it was boarded up when its current owner bought it in 2019, and that the work since then has included new bathrooms and a new kitchen, refinished original hardwood floors, and exterior brick pavers taken from a former horse farm in Arcadia. The 2,975-square-foot home has three bedrooms, a third-floor den and two and a half baths. It went on the market in December 2025 at $898,000. That asking price is for a century-old house with original floors and a construction crane in its third-floor window.

The third price is the regional one. The Royal Palm Coast Realtor Association reported a median condo and townhouse sale price of $223,750 for October 2026, up 1.7 percent from September. That figure is a different product in a different place, and the next section explains why it cannot be used to price ONE.

Why the Resale Median Cannot Price ONE

The association's monthly statistics cover Lee and Hendry counties, excluding Bonita Springs and Estero. The condo median mixes garden units in Cape Coral and Lehigh Acres with towers on the river, so it describes the region's resale inventory and says little about any one building.

What it does describe well is the resale market's balance this fall. In October 2026, new condo and townhouse listings rose 42.7 percent from September to 648, median days on market came in at 72, and supply reached 10.5 months. That supply figure was up from September but 13.9 percent below October 2025. Single-family homes in the same report sold at a $369,999 median with 7.5 months of supply and 42 median days on market. Supply that deep before season gives buyers room to negotiate and plenty to choose from.

ONE's starting price of $1.3 million is more than five times that regional condo median. The project's website lists the tower as 50 percent sold with limited inventory remaining. An earlier Gulfshore Business report put it at about 45 percent. Those buyers are paying for something the 10.5 months of resale supply does not contain: new riverfront construction downtown. Gulfshore Business called ONE the first riverfront condominium tower to rise in downtown Fort Myers since Oasis in 2006. The developer's own marketing goes further. It says falling land availability and rising costs have made another boutique high-rise in the River District "nearly impossible." That is a sales claim, and buyers should read it as one. The 20-year gap since Oasis is a fact.

The design is part of what that money buys. WBBH reported in April that ONE has elevated parking, with residences starting on the third floor, 40 feet above the ground. Pesche Robinson, the project's sales director, told the station that buyers are coming to "an area where you can still have reasonable cost to live in waterfront and new construction," and pointed to the expansion at the airport. A buyer who compares ONE with the Naples waterfront is making the comparison she describes. A buyer who compares it with the Lee County condo median is not.

First Street Runs on Several Clocks

The tower's 2027 completion date is one of several on this stretch of the river, and buyers should set them side by side.

The first has already arrived. Legacy Harbour Marina officially reopened in September 2026 with 131 slips from 40 to 140 feet, a fuel dock, in-slip pump-out, and both single- and three-phase power. AIRN Management rebuilt it with Bellingham Marine. WINK reported that a marina staff member said downtown restaurants had been down about 30 percent in revenue after all three downtown marinas were destroyed. The same report said the neighboring restaurant, Nelly's Boatyard, was slated to open in December. So the boat traffic that feeds First Street's dining rooms has returned a full year before ONE's projected finish.

Small businesses have opened too. WBBH named Café Chocolattés and Point Ybel Brewing among the new arrivals on West First Street. The same report said Triton Cay's second phase, an eight-story apartment building, was moving forward. Steve Brantner, who has run Steve B. Waterfront Café and Biergarten on the street for 15 years, told the station he is "riding the wave, you know, just watching it happen every day at a time."

The next date falls close to ONE's. Robinson told WBBH that Marriott plans to convert Royal Palm Towers into a 196-room hotel by December 2027. In the same report, a Hilton Tempo hotel at First and Jackson Streets was still listed as proposed. Mayor Kevin Anderson tied the hotel push to the convention center, which he said is limited in the size of conventions it can hold by the hotel rooms nearby. He also said the city will eventually need a fourth parking garage. The parking garage has no timeline yet. That matters to anyone who expects to host guests at a downtown condo.

The last date is still open. As of WBBH's April 2026 report, the city's Yacht Basin, empty since Hurricane Ian, was waiting on Army Corps of Engineers permits. Anderson said that once those permits are issued, "you're going to see over $100 million worth of development in and around the basin."

Matching the Purchase to the Date You Want

These dates help sort the three prices on the block. A buyer who signs at ONE will take delivery around the end of 2027. That is about when the Marriott conversion is due, more than a year after the marina came back, and on no fixed schedule relative to the Yacht Basin. Part of the price over the regional median pays for being early to the newest building on the river. Part pays for waiting through two more seasons of construction before moving in.

A buyer who wants First Street as it stands this winter has the street's older housing to choose from. High Point Place alone has 273 units, a pool and a fitness center. Those older towers sit inside the same resale market where October's supply reached 10.5 months, so they come with the negotiating room that market allows. The house at 2582 First St. is a third option: a century-old house given a careful, design-led renovation and priced for the street the new construction is building around it.

The surrounding neighborhoods have the same layering. Edison Park, platted in January 1926, and Dean Park are both established local historic districts in Fort Myers, designated in 1995 and 1997 according to Historic Preservation Commission minutes. Their older homes trade at a different pace from the new towers going up downtown, much as the houses on First Street do. Our guide to Fort Myers riverfront homes as investments covers the single-family side. For the evenings these purchases are meant to buy, see the Fridays and Saturday that shape the River District. For boat owners, Legacy Harbour's slip sizes are worth reading alongside what "gulf access" means in Fort Myers.

If you are weighing a preconstruction contract downtown against a resale unit in one of the established towers, or a restored house like the one across from ONE, Jodi Hanson can walk you through what each address on the Fort Myers riverfront is pricing in, and which completion date it is tied to. Get Access to Our Private Listings.

Work With Jodi

Passionate about helping buyers find homes that they connect with emotionally, Jodi is able to draw upon her own investment experience to advise them on which properties have the most potential for financial gain.

Follow Me On Instagram